Why we chose it
It’s the closest thing we found to real evidence, rather than opinion, that fantasy is ordinary. That fact alone does a lot of quiet work in a deck built to make private curiosities sayable between partners.
Adults only · 18+ · For the After Dark edition
The shelf behind the deck · After Dark · 18+
Tell Me What You Want
Justin J. Lehmiller, Ph.D. — social psychologist, Kinsey InstituteOne of the largest surveys ever run on what people actually fantasise about — thousands of respondents, mapped into a small number of recurring themes, and a calm case for why naming a fantasy out loud does less damage than keeping it secret.
Feeds into
After Dark — disclosure prompts
Read more on Letturia →
What the book is about
The largest map of fantasy we have, treated as data, not confession.
Tell Me What You Want is social psychologist Justin J. Lehmiller’s 2018 report on one of the largest studies of sexual fantasy ever conducted — a survey that ran to well over four thousand respondents across the United States, asked in detail about what they actually imagine, not what they think they should.
Lehmiller, a researcher affiliated with the Kinsey Institute, set out to replace guesswork and shame with an actual dataset. Rather than treating fantasy as a symptom to be explained away, the book reports it as a normal, near-universal feature of sexuality, sorted into recognisable clusters that show up again and again across different people’s answers.
The tone throughout is curious rather than clinical or titillating: it reads like a researcher genuinely interested in what people carry around in their heads, and in why so many of them have never told anyone.
Core ideas
What the research actually found.
- Sexual fantasy is close to universal and enormously varied, yet it clusters into a handful of recurring themes: multi-partner scenarios, power and control, novelty and adventure, taboo, sharing a partner or non-monogamy, passion and romance, and gender-bending or same-sex attraction regardless of orientation.
- Fantasy is not prophecy. Wanting something in imagination is not the same as wanting it in real life, and most people never act on most of what they fantasise about — the imagining is often the point.
- Personality and attachment style shape what a person tends to fantasise about, which means a fantasy says something about psychology, not about character or fidelity.
- Shame and secrecy around fantasy cause more damage than the fantasies themselves. Couples who can discuss fantasy, selectively and kindly, tend to report better sexual satisfaction — with the understanding that sharing one is never a demand to act on it.
From shelf to table
Why we chose it, and how we used it.
How we used it for the cards
The book’s clearest, most useful distinction — between fantasy as something imagined and fantasy as something requested — became the spine of After Dark’s disclosure prompts. A card can invite someone to name a fantasy without it being read as a demand that a partner fulfil it; telling and asking-for are kept deliberately separate.
As with every card in the deck, disclosure prompts can be passed, paused, swapped, or stopped, no explanation required.
Where “informed” ends
Cited as inspiration. Not affiliated. Not endorsed.
Dr. Justin J. Lehmiller, the Kinsey Institute, and the book’s publishers have not endorsed, reviewed, or been involved with Meet Me Gently in any way. The book is cited here as inspiration and recommended reading only, nothing more.
Meet Me Gently is an educational conversation deck, not therapy, diagnosis, or treatment, and no card can tell you whether a relationship is safe for you. After Dark is an 18+ add-on for consenting adults, sold sealed and never alone, and every card in it — like every card in the deck — can be passed, paused, swapped, or stopped. See the full inspiration page for our complete reading list and honest boundaries.
Keep reading
More from the shelf.
Back to the table